Accretion of warm chondrules in weakly metamorphosed ordinary chondrites and their subsequent reprocessing

aAlex M. Ruzicka, aRichard C. Hugo, b,cJon M. Friedrich, aMichael T. Ream
Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta (in Press)
Link to Article [https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gca.2024.05.031]
aCascadia Meteorite Laboratory, Department of Geology, Portland State University, 1721 SW Broadway, Portland, OR 97207, USA
bDepartment of Chemistry, Fordham University, Bronx, NY 10458, USA
cDepartment of Earth and Planetary Science, American Museum of Natural History, New York, NY 10024, USA
Copyright Elsevier

To better understand chondrite accretion and subsequent processes, the textures, crystallography, deformation, and compositions of some chondrite constituents in ten lithologies of different cluster texture strength were studied in seven weakly metamorphosed (Type 3) and variably shocked ordinary chondrites (Ragland—LL3 S1, Tieschitz—H/L3 S1, NWA 5421—LL3 S2, NWA 5205—LL3 S2, NWA 11905—LL3-5 S3, NWA 5781—LL3 S3, NWA 11351—LL3-6 S4) using optical and electron microscopy and microtomography techniques.

Results support a four-stage model for chondrite formation. This includes 1) limited annealing following collisions during chondrule crystallization and rapid cooling in space prior to accretion, as evidenced by olivine microstructures consistent with dislocation recovery and diffusion; 2) initial accretion of still-warm chondrules into aggregates at an effective chondrite accretion temperature of ∼900-950 °C with nearly in situ impingement deformation between adjacent chondrules in strongly clustered lithologies (NWA 5781, Tieschitz, NWA 5421, NWA 5205 Lithology A), as evidenced by intragranular lattice distortions in olivine consistent with high-temperature slip systems, and by evidence that some olivine-rich objects in Tieschitz accreted while partly molten; 3) syn- or post-accretion bleaching of chondrule mesostases, which transferred feldspathic chondrule mesostasis to an interchondrule glass deposit found in strongly clustered lithologies, as evidenced by chemical data and textures; and 4) post-bleaching weak or strong shocks that resulted in destruction of interchondrule glass and some combination of brecciation, foliation of metal and sulfide, and melting and shock-overprinting effects, as evidenced by poor cluster textures and presence of clastic texture, alignment of metal and sulfide grains caused by shock compression, presence of impact-generated glass, and changes in olivine slip systems. The data support the model of Metzler (2012), who suggested that chondrules in ordinary chondrites accreted while still warm to form cluster chondrite textures as a “primary accretionary rock” (our Stage 2), and that subsequent brecciation destroyed this texture to create chondrites with weak cluster texture (our Stage 4).

The formation of volatile-bearing djerfisherite in reduced meteorites

Zoë E. Wilbur1, Timothy J. McCoy2, Catherine M. Corrigan2, Jessica J. Barnes1, Sierra V. Brown3, Arya Udry4
Meteoritics & Planetary Science (in Press) Open Access
Link to Article [https://doi.org/10.1111/maps.14220]
1Lunar and Planetary Laboratory, University of Arizona, Tucson, Arizona, USA
2Department of Mineral Sciences, National Museum of Natural History, Smithsonian Institution, Washington, District of
Columbia, USA
3Million Concepts, LLC, Louisville, Kentucky, USA
4University of Nevada, Las Vegas, Nevada, USA

Published by arrangement with John Wiley & Sons

Enstatite meteorites, both aubrites and enstatite chondrites, formed under exceptionally reducing conditions, similar to the planet Mercury. Despite being reduced, the MESSENGER mission showed that the surface of Mercury is more enriched in volatiles (e.g., S, Na, K, Cl) than previously thought. To better understand the mineral hosts of these volatiles and how they formed, this work examines the chemistry and petrographic settings of a rare, K-bearing sulfide called djerfisherite within enstatite chondrites and aubrites. The petrographic settings of djerfisherite within aubrites suggest this critical host of Cl formed after both the crystallization of troilite and exsolution of daubréelite. Djerfisherite is commonly observed as a rim on other sulfides and in contact with metal. We present an alteration model for djerfisherite formation in aubrite meteorites, whereby troilite and Fe-Ni metal are altered through anhydrous, alkali- and Cl-rich fluid metasomatism on the aubrite parent body to produce secondary djerfisherite. Moreover, we observe a loss of volatiles in djerfisherite within impact melted regions of the Miller Range 07139 EH3 chondrite and the Bishopville aubrite and explore the potential for impact devolatilization changes to sulfide chemistry on other reduced bodies in the Solar System. Vapor or fluid phase interactions are likely important in the formation of volatile-rich phases in reduced systems. While most Na and K on the mercurian surface is expected to be hosted in feldspar, djerfisherite is likely a minor, but critical, reservoir for K, Na, and Cl. Djerfisherite present on reduced bodies, such as Mercury, may represent sulfides formed via late-stage, primary metasomatism.

Condensation of refractory minerals on igneous compact type A Ca-Al-rich inclusion from Northwest Africa 7865 CV chondrite

Akimasa Suzumura1,3, Noriyuki Kawasaki2, Hisayoshi Yurimoto2, Shoichi Itoh1
Meteoritics & Planetary Science (in Press) Open Access
Link to Article [https://doi.org/10.1111/maps.14222]
1Department of Earth and Planetary Sciences, Kyoto University, Kyoto, Japan
2Department of Natural History Sciences, Hokkaido University, Sapporo, Japan
3Graduate School of Human and Environmental Studies, Kyoto University, Kyoto, Japan
Published by arrangement with John Wiley & Sons

A melilite-rich, compact type A Ca-Al-rich inclusion (CAI), KU-N-02, from the reduced CV3 chondrite Northwest Africa 7865, is mantled by an åkermanite-poor layer. We carried out a combined study of petrographic observations and in situ O and Al–Mg isotopic measurements for KU-N-02. The core shows a typical texture of igneous compact type A CAIs. The mantle consists of spinel, åkermanite-poor melilite, and perovskite. Individual mantle melilite crystals show reverse zoning toward the crystal grain boundary, in contrast to core melilite crystals showing normal zoning. The O isotopic compositions of the minerals in KU-N-02 plot along the carbonaceous chondrite anhydrous mineral line on a three O-isotope diagram. The mantle and core spinel crystals are uniformly 16O-rich (Δ17O ~ −23‰). The mantle melilite crystals exhibit variable O isotopic compositions ranging between Δ17O ~ −2‰ and −9‰, in contrast to the uniformly 16O-poor (Δ17O ~ −2‰) core melilite. The mantle melilite crystals also exhibit variable δ25Mg values (δ25MgDSM-3 ~ −2‰ to +3‰) compared with the nearly constant δ25Mg values of the core melilite (δ25MgDSM-3 ~ +2‰). The mantle minerals are likely to have formed by condensation from the solar nebular gas after core formation. The Al–Mg mineral isochrons of the core and mantle give initial 26Al/27Al ratios of (4.66 ± 0.15) × 10−5 and (4.74 ± 0.14) × 10−5, respectively. The age difference between the core and mantle formation is estimated to be within ~0.05 Myr, implying that both melting and condensation processes in the variable O isotopically solar nebular environments occurred within a short time during single CAI formation.

Plagioclase iron content variance: A complication for efforts to identify lunar terrains of extremely high plagioclase abundance

1Paul H. Warren,2Junko Isa,1Bidong Zhang,3Randy L. Korotev
Icarus (in Press) Open Access Link to Article [https://doi.org/10.1016/j.icarus.2024.116144]
1Department of Earth, Planetary and Space Science, UCLA, Los Angeles, CA 90095, USA
2Cold Pine Observatory, 201, 4-22, Matsugaoka 1-cho me, Chigasaki, Kanagawa, Japan
3Department of Earth, Environmental, and Planetary Sciences, Washington University, St. Louis, MO 63130, USA
Copyright Elsevier

According to several orbital reflectance spectroscopy studies, numerous widely scattered lunar surface locales feature remarkably high (>98%) abundance of plagioclase. These “pure” anorthosite claims are based on an absorption band at ~1.25 μm, associated with minor Fe2+ within plagioclase. But utilization of the 1.25 μm band as a direct gauge of plagioclase abundance requires an underlying assumption that plagioclase FeO is uniform across all measured materials. Available data for FeO in lunar plagioclase are in many cases suspect because electron-probe FeO measurements may be inflated by secondary fluorescence from nearby mafic phases. We studied plagioclase FeO in a set of 13 anorthositic lunar rocks, taking care to avoid proximity to mafic phases; or in cases where complete avoidance was not possible without sacrificing representativeness (i.e., fine-grained impact melt rocks with zoned silicates), correcting close-to-mafic analyses for secondary fluorescence (Sugawara, T. [2001], Japanese Mag. Mineral. Petrol. Sci. 30, 159–163). Results for rock-average plagioclase FeO range from 0.030 wt% in plutonic troctolitic anorthosite 76,335, to 0.23 wt% in impact-melt rock 14,310. In general, as shown by exsolution of mafic silicates from plagioclase within several samples, final plagioclase FeO in lunar plutonic anorthosites is determined by reequilibration during slow postigneous cooling and/or metamorphism. In contrast, four fast-cooled anorthositic impact melt rocks have consistently higher plagioclase FeO, averaging 1.9 times higher in comparison to average plutonic anorthositic rock. Thus, impact melted lunar anorthosite will have far more prominent 1.25 μm absorption than plutonic anorthosite of the same plagioclase abundance. In view of the inconstancy of plagioclase FeO, orbital spectral reflectance using the 1.25 μm absorption band, or the ratio between that band and one or more mafic silicate bands, cannot be precise enough to justify claims of ability to resolve “purest” (98 vol% +) anorthosite from compositions that are high-plagioclase but not that extreme.

The anomalous polymict ordinary chondrite breccia of Elmshorn (H3-6)—Late reaccretion after collision between two ordinary chondrite parent bodies, complete disruption, and mixing possibly about 2.8 Gyr ago

1Addi Bischoff et al. (>10)
Meteoritics & Planetary Science (in Press) Open Access Link to Article [https://doi.org/10.1111/maps.14193]
1Institut für Planetologie, University of Münster, Münster, Germany
Published by arrangement with John Wiley & Sons

Elmshorn fell April 25, 2023, about 30 km northwest of the city of Hamburg (Germany). Shortly after the fall, 21 pieces were recovered totaling a mass of 4277 g. Elmshorn is a polymict and anomalous H3-6 chondritic, fragmental breccia. The rock is a mixture of typical H chondrite lithologies and clasts of intermediate H/L (or L, based on magnetic properties) chondrite origin. In some of the 21 pieces, the H chondrite lithologies dominate, while in others the H/L (or L) chondrite components are prevalent. The H/L chondrite assignment of these components is based on the mean composition of their olivines in equilibrated type 4 fragments (~Fa21–22). The physical properties like density (3.34 g cm−3) and magnetic susceptibility (logχ <5.0, with χ in 10−9 m3 kg−1) are typical for L chondrites, which is inconsistent with the oxygen isotope compositions: all eight O isotope analyses from two different fragments clearly fall into the H chondrite field. Thus, the fragments found in the strewn field vary in mineralogy, mineral chemistry, and physical properties but not in O isotope characteristics. The sample most intensively studied belongs to the stones dominated by H chondrite lithologies. The chemical composition and nucleosynthetic Cr and Ti isotope data are typical for ordinary chondrites. The noble gases in Elmshorn represent a mixture between cosmogenic, radiogenic, and primordially trapped noble gases, while a solar wind component can be excluded. Because the chondritic rock of Elmshorn contains (a) H chondrite parent body interior materials (of types 5 and 6), (b) chondrite parent body near-surface materials (of types 3 and 4), (c) fragments of an H/L chondrite (dominant in many stones), (d) shock-darkened fragments, and (e) clasts of various types of impact melts but no solar wind-implanted noble gases, the different components cannot have been part of a parent body regolith. The most straightforward explanation is that the fragmental breccia of Elmshorn represents a reaccreted rock after a catastrophic collision between an H chondrite parent body and another body with H/L (or L) chondrite characteristics but with deviating O isotope values (i.e. that of H chondrites), complete disruption of the bodies, mixing, and reassembly. This is the only straightforward way that the implantation of solar wind gases could have been avoided in this kind of complex breccia. The gas retention ages of about 2.8 Gyr possibly indicate the closure time after the catastrophic collision between H and H/L (or L) chondrite parent bodies, while the cosmic ray exposure age for Elmshorn, which had a preatmospheric radius of 25–40 cm, is ~17–20 Myr.

The Aguas Zarcas carbonaceous chondrite meteorite: Brecciation and aqueous alteration on the parent body

1I. Kouvatsis,2,3J. A. Cartwright,1W. E. Hames
Meteoritics & Planetary Science (in Press) Link to Article [https://doi.org/10.1111/maps.14219]
1Department of Geological Sciences, University of Alabama, Tuscaloosa, Alabama, USA
2School of Physics and Astronomy, Institute for Space, University of Leicester, Leicester, UK
3Institute for Space, Space Park Leicester, University of Leicester, Leicester, UK
Published by arrangement with John Wiley & Sons

CM chondrites are samples from primitive water-rich asteroids that formed early in the solar system; many record evidence for silicate rock–liquid water interaction. Many CM chondrites also exhibit well-developed fine-grained rims (FGRs) that surround major components, including chondrules and refractory inclusions. Previous studies have shown that Aguas Zarcas, a CM2 chondrite fall recovered in 2019, is a breccia consisting of several lithologies. Here, we present a study of Aguas Zarcas using optical microscopy, scanning electron microscopy, and electron probe microanalysis, focusing on brecciation and aqueous alteration on the parent body. We observed two lithologies within our sample, separated by a distinct textural and chemical boundary. The first lithology has a higher chondrule abundance (“chondrule-rich”) and significantly larger FGRs compared to the second lithology (“chondrule-poor”), even for similarly sized chondrules. We observed clear compositional differences between the two lithologies and more multilayered FGRs in the chondrule-rich lithology. We determined that the chondrule-rich lithology is less altered (petrologic type 2.7–2.8) and displays larger FGRs to chondrule ratios compared to the more altered chondrule-poor lithology (petrologic type 2.5–2.6). These observations are contrary to previous models that predict aqueous alteration as a cause of FGR formation in the parent body. Our observed differences in Mg and Fe distribution in the lithology matrices alongside variable FGR thickness suggest distinct formation environments. We propose that the Aguas Zarcas parent body was subjected to several minor and major brecciation events that mixed different materials with variable degrees of aqueous alteration together, in agreement with previous studies.

Detection and quantification of organosulfur species in the Tagish Lake Meteorite by highly sensitive LC-MS

1N. Randazzo,1R. W. Hilts,1M. C. Holt,1C. D. K. Herd,2B. Reiz,2R. M. Whittal
Meteoritics & Planetary Science (in Press) Open Access Link to Article [https://doi.org/10.1111/maps.14189]
1Department of Earth and Atmospheric Sciences, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
2Department of Chemistry, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
Published by arrangement with John Wiley & Sons

We analyzed the methanol extracts of six pristine specimens of the Tagish Lake meteorite (TL1, TL4, TL5A, TL6, TL7, and TL10a) and heated and unheated samples of Allende using high-performance liquid chromatography coupled with high-resolution, accurate mass–mass spectrometry (HPLC-HRAM-MS). All samples contained ppm levels of sulfate and methyl sulfate. The most abundant organosulfur compound in the methanol extracts of the Tagish Lake and Allende samples was methyl sulfate, which was likely formed primarily via an esterification reaction between intrinsic sources of methanol and sulfate. A homologous series of polythionic acids was also observed in the extracts of the Tagish Lake specimens and Allende. The polythionic acids were the most abundant soluble inorganic sulfur species found in the meteorites. Our results were confirmed using retention time, accurate mass, isotope matching, and tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS). Hydroxymethanesulfonic acid, previously reported in Tagish Lake, was found only in an unheated Allende sample and in low abundance. Here, we propose possible sulfate formation pathways that begin with interstellar dimethyl sulfide, dimethyl disulfide, methyl sulfide, or methanethiol via cold, nebular processes within the interstellar medium and continue via MSA as an intermediary compound ending within planetary bodies with sulfate and methyl sulfate as the final products.

The fireball of November 24, 1970, as the most probable source of the Ischgl meteorite

1,2,3,4Maria Gritsevich et al.(>10)
Meteoritics & Planetary Science (in Press) Open Access Link to Article [https://doi.org/10.1111/maps.14173]
1Faculty of Science, University of Helsinki, Helsinki, Finland
2Swedish Institute of Space Physics (IRF), Kiruna, Sweden
3Finnish Fireball Network, Ursa Astronomical Association, Helsinki, Finland
4Institute of Physics and Technology, Ural Federal University, Ekaterinburg, Russia
Published by arrangement with John Wiley & Sons

The discovery of the Ischgl meteorite unfolded in a captivating manner. In June 1976, a pristine meteorite stone weighing approximately 1 kg, fully covered with a fresh black fusion crust, was collected on a mountain road in the high-altitude Alpine environment. The recovery took place while clearing the remnants of a snow avalanche, 2 km northwest of the town of Ischgl in Austria. Subsequent to its retrieval, the specimen remained tucked away in the finder’s private residence without undergoing any scientific examination or identification until 2008, when it was brought to the University of Innsbruck. Upon evaluation, the sample was classified as a well-preserved LL6 chondrite, with a W0 weathering grade, implying a relatively short time between the meteorite fall and its retrieval. To investigate the potential connection between the Ischgl meteorite and a recorded fireball event, we have reviewed all documented fireballs ever photographed by German fireball camera stations. This examination led us to identify the fireball EN241170 observed in Germany by 10 different European Network stations on the night of November 23/24, 1970, as the most likely candidate. We employed state-of-the-art techniques to reconstruct the fireball’s trajectory and to reproduce both its luminous and dark flight phases in detail. We find that the determined strewn field and the generated heat map closely align with the recovery location of the Ischgl meteorite. Furthermore, the measured radionuclide data reported here indicate that the pre-atmospheric size of the Ischgl meteoroid is consistent with the mass estimate inferred from our deceleration analysis along the trajectory. Our findings strongly support the conclusion that the Ischgl meteorite originated from the EN241170 fireball, effectively establishing it as a confirmed meteorite fall. This discovery enables to determine, along with the physical properties, also the heliocentric orbit and cosmic history of the Ischgl meteorite.

Petrological, chemical, and chronological study of breccias in the Chang’e-5 soil

1,2Yuruo Shi et al. (>10)
Meteoritics & Planetary Science (in Press)Link to Article [https://doi.org/10.1111/maps.14192]
1Key Laboratory of Gold Mineralization Processes and Resource Utilization, MNR, Shandong Provincial Key Laboratory of Metallogenic Geological Process and Resource Utilization, Shandong Institute of Geological Sciences, Jinan, China
2Beijing SHRIMP Center, Institute of Geology, Chinese Academy of Geological Sciences, Beijing, China
Published by arrangement with John Wiley & Sons

We carried out a petrological, mineralogical, and geochemical study of fragmental and regolith breccia clasts separated from two Chang’e-5 (CE-5) soil samples, CE5C0000YJYX03501GP and CE5C0400, which provide an opportunity to investigate the compositional change of regolith at the landing site through time. Fragmental breccia CE-5-B3 contains a diverse range of basaltic clasts and basaltic mineral fragments, and some rare Mg-suite-like minerals. Regolith breccias CE-5-B006, CE-5-B007, CE-5-B010-08, CE-5-B010-09, CE-5-B011-07, and CE-5-B016-03 contain mare basaltic fragments, mare vitrophyric clasts, rare Mg-rich fragments possibly derived from the Mg-suite rocks, and impact-derived glass spherules. Pb-isotope data obtained for baddeleyite grains found both inside some of the basaltic clasts identified in breccia fragments and in the breccia matrices yield Pb/Pb dates similar to the 2 Ga crystallization age of the CE-5 basalt fragments, extracted directly from the soil sample. Seventy-four Pb isotope analyses of Ca-phosphate grains also indicate that the majority of these grains have Pb/Pb dates of 2 Ga, suggesting that they originate from the CE-5 basalts. In addition, a Pb–Pb isochron drawn through analyses of four Ca-phosphates in breccia CE5-B006 yielded an intercept corresponding to a date of 3871 ± 46 Ma, which is the best possible estimate of the formation age of these four grains. Electron probe microanalysis shows that the breccias contain components similar to CE-5 mare basalt fragments extracted directly from the soil sample, implying that the fragmental and regolith breccia fragments are mostly composed of material sourced from the underlying basalts. The general absence of impact melt breccia clasts, along with the general lack of Fe–Ni metal and absence of added meteoritic debris all suggest that the regolith at the CE-5 landing site is immature and dominated by material mixed together by small local impact cratering events. Trace element analyses show that the glass beads in the regolith breccias have a Th abundance of 4.06–5.28 μg g−1. This is similar to the Th content of the regolith above the Em4 unit at the landing site as measured from orbit, as well as the estimated bulk Th content of CE-5 basalts, suggesting that Th of the local regolith is predominantly sourced from the underlying mare basalts, without significant Th addition from Th-rich exotic clasts sourced from evolved lunar lithologies.

A shallow (~100km) ilmenite-bearing pyroxenitic source for young lunar volcanism

1Chengyuan Wang,1Yi-Gang Xu,1Le Zhang,1Zhiming Chen,1Xiaoping Xia,1Mang Lin,1Feng Guo
Earth and Planetary Science Letters 693, 118770 Link to Article [https://doi.org/10.1016/j.epsl.2024.118770]
1State Key Laboratory of Isotope Geochemistry, Guangzhou Institute of Geochemistry, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Guangzhou 510640, PR China
Copyright Elsevier

The lunar magma ocean (LMO) hypothesis predicts that the uppermost mantle (∼60–100 km) is composed of ilmenite-bearing cumulate (IBC), which may have sunk deeply due to gravitational instability. However, the extent to which this process restructured the lunar mantle and influenced mare volcanism remains unclear. Here, we approach this issue by examining pyroxenes in Chang’E-5 (CE5) basalts and petrological modeling. We show that the low Mg# and negative anomalies in Ti and Ta of CE5 basalts cannot be produced by extensive fractionation of peridotite-derived low-Ti basalts, but were most likely formed through partial melting of a shallow (< 100 km) IBC pyroxenite source. This model is also applicable to the ∼3.0 Ga lunar basaltic meteorites. The increasing involvement of IBC sources in young lunar magmas, also revealed by the remote-sensing data, implies an inefficient gravitational restructuring process during the late LMO stage and provides new insights into the thermochemical state of the lunar interior.