Bounding the unknowns of Martian crustal heat flow from a synthesis of regional geochemistry and InSight mission data

1Katelyn R. Frizzell,1Lujendra Ojha,2Suniti Karunatillake
Icarus (in Press) Link to Article [https://doi.org/10.1016/j.icarus.2023.115700]
1Department of Earth and Planetary Sciences, Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey, Piscataway, NJ 08854, USA
1Louisiana State University, Baton Rouge, LA, USA
Copyright Elsevier

The thermal evolution of terrestrial planets is primarily modulated by the distribution of heat-producing elements (HPE) within the crust and mantle. Chemical data from Martian meteorites suggest that Mars differentiated early, which led to an early partitioning of incompatible heat-producing elements in the crust. Previous estimates of Martian crustal heat flow that used the bulk regolith abundances of HPEs from the Gamma-Ray Spectrometer (GRS) suite on Mars Odyssey spacecraft have further corroborated this view of Mars, albeit with poorly known crustal column representativeness. Here we couple the GRS-derived chemical maps of Mars with estimates of crustal thickness and density from the InSight lander to revise the estimated Martian crustal heat flow. The mean crustal heat flow values range from 3.0 to 13.9 mW m−2 for the endmember gravity-derived crustal thickness models anchored by constraints from InSight. We also estimate the crustal heat flow from other factors such as the distribution of HPEs with depth and the Uranium content of the crust. Our results suggest that the mean crustal heat flow varies substantially across models, with the highest mean values being associated with higher densities and an increased enrichment of HPEs with depth. Further work is needed to constrain the crustal thickness of Mars, as the largest uncertainties in the estimate of crustal heat flow stem from uncertainty in the crustal thickness estimates, not geochemical variability. The results from this work corroborate previous estimates of a strong fractionation of heat-producing elements into the Martian crust.

In-situ phosphate U-Pb ages of the L chondrites

  • 1Craig Robert Walton et al. (>10)
    Geochmica et Cosmochimica Acta (in Press) Open Access Link to Article [https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gca.2023.07.012]
    1University of Cambridge, Institute of Astronomy, Madingley Road, Cambridge, CB3 0HA, United Kingdom
    Copyright Elsevier

The thermal history of asteroids is recorded by the radioisotopic ages of meteorites that derive from them. Radioisotopic ages may date a number of events, such as the cooling of a parent body during waning radiogenic metamorphism, rapid cooling experienced upon parent body break-up, and/or subsequent collision-induced reheating of material. However, sampling statistics for meteorite radioisotope ages are currently relatively low and most are derived from analyses of bulk material, therefore lacking the in-situ microtextural context that aids in distinguishing collisional events. Here, we present new in-situ apatite U-Pb ages for nine L chondrite meteorites using secondary ionisation mass spectrometry.

Our measurements greatly expand the L chondrite phosphate U-Pb age record and provide evidence for distinct stages in the thermal evolution of the L chondrite parent asteroid, including: early collisions driving parent body fragmentation- and/or exhumation-associated cooling at > 4530 Ma; onion-shell-style cooling with waning radiogenic metamorphism until 4500 Ma; late collisional reheating from 4480–4460 Ma; parent body break-up at 474± 22 Ma; and recent ejection events within several 10s of Myr of present day. We show that meteorite shock stage correlates with upper intercept age but is uncorrelated with lower intercept age. This outcome links the upper intercept ages alone to the preserved high-energy impact-related features in strongly shocked meteorites, which has important implications for our interpretation of the L chondrite U-Pb record.

We see no evidence in our record for collisional episodes between 3000–4400 Ma, i.e., the Late Heavy Bombardment. Our upper intercept age record hints that collision rates changed as a result of some dynamical instability at 4460–4480 Ma, which may have strongly depleted the main asteroid belt, and/or that L asteroid physical structure changed such that the shock metamorphic response to collisions was muted after this time, e.g., by the formation of weak rubble pile bodies. L chondrite phosphate U-Pb ages provide evidence for a heterogeneous early and shared late (less than 500 Ma) thermal history for the majority of L chondrite meteorites falling to Earth today. From this observation, we infer that most L chondrites derive from a single parent asteroid (in existence from around 4500–4440 Ma to 474± 22 Ma), which has since been disturbed to create an asteroid family. Our record of meteorite U-Pb ages traces out the thermal and dynamical evolution of the L chondrite asteroid. These observations can be used in future to benchmark dynamical models of Solar System evolution.